TrustRadius: an HG Insights company

Acoustic Campaign

Score6.3 out of 10

125 Reviews and Ratings

What is Acoustic Campaign?

Acoustic Campaign (formerly IBM Watson Campaign Automation) is a scalable, SaaS-based, cross-channel, digital marketing platform providing digital marketers the ability to implement and manage email, mobile, social, and lead management campaign processes.

Media

Digital marketing
Journey design

1 / 2

Top Performing Features

  • Dynamic content

    Users can tailor email, website or landing page content depending on the viewer or recipient (e.g., email salutations that include the recipient’s name).

    Category average: 7.9

  • Email deliverability reporting

    The software helps ensure inbox delivery of email campaigns, through features such as deliverability tests, opt-in management, bounce handling, suppression lists, dedicated IP addresses, and delivery monitoring.

    Category average: 8.2

  • List management

    This involves creating, filtering, editing, merging and de-duping lists of contacts.

    Category average: 8.5

Areas for Improvement

  • Dashboards

    Users can create, customize and share dashboards, which provide an overview of the most important metrics.

    Category average: 7.6

  • Standard reports

    The software offers pre-built reports with metrics standard to the category.

    Category average: 7.7

  • WYSIWYG email editor

    Users can create html emails through a drag-and-drop interface, without html coding knowledge.

    Category average: 8.2

Powerful, but clunky and hasn't innovated fast enough

Pros

  • Flexibility in using to data: databases (including relational databases), segmentation and powerful querying.
  • Personalization and conditional content for email as well as landing pages.
  • PURLs to extend personalization in direct mail.

Cons

  • The interface is clunky and heavy, resulting in a slow UX. This is particularly true with the email builder.
  • Processing of data (eg. returning a list of contacts for a query) is handled via 'Jobs', which means that it's not a dynamic process. Jobs need to start, crunch and end before you get a result.
  • Reporting

Return on Investment

  • ROI very much depends on the strategy driving a data-driven marketing project, and not so much the platform itself.
  • IBM Watson Campaign Automation is more expensive than other platforms to use, day in day out, because of its clunky interface.
  • It's a flexible product and can achieve more than most.

Alternatives Considered

HubSpot CRM, HubSpot, HubSpot Sales, Adobe Campaign and ActiveCampaign

Other Software Used

ActiveCampaign, cPanel, WordPress, HubSpot, Trello, Teamwork Projects, Teamwork Desk

Nice integration between b2b and b2c

Pros

  • Marketing campaign to customers
  • Sending the policy of insurance to customers to certify receipt

Cons

  • The main [area for] improvement would be the user interface..... it’s extremely hard to compare to Eloqua or Responsys
  • Reports !!! Please include Watson Analytics or something !!

Return on Investment

  • Quick B2C and B2B integration
  • Very hard to implement

Alternatives Considered

Oracle Responsys and Oracle Eloqua

Other Software Used

Oracle Responsys, Oracle Eloqua

Although there is a learning curve, mastering IBM WCA can prove beneficial for your email services.

Pros

  • Data integration / segmentation / list management -- the opportunities to segment and test data is second to none within WCA.
  • Reporting -- Silverpop has pretty much everything I need for reporting
  • Comprehensive -- Silverpop has virtually every tool I need for email marketing.

Cons

  • Template Builder -- Can be very buggy with certain chrome extensions (i.e. Grammarly), can be slow to refresh when making changes, no auto-save features, requires HTML knowledge.
  • Clunky UI/UX -- Overall, little time-saving features (Such as recognizing when you're in a folder and wanting to save a copy in that same folder or creating queries for people who don't open emails) seem to be overlooked.

Return on Investment

  • Overall it has been positive from an agency standpoint, however the lack of accessibility and ease has created a difficult learning curve for our self service customers.

Other Software Used

Campaign Monitor, Mailchimp, Infusionsoft

Hopeful that Acoustic will continue to improve and evolve from what IBM was

Pros

  • Setting up complex email journeys.
  • Scoring models for contacts.

Cons

  • Currently no simple drag and drop email template editor.
  • Fragmented/not intuitive reporting-- You have to go to a few different places to piece together information.

Return on Investment

  • Email fell from 57% of our traffic to just over 40% from 2018 to 2019 with the introduction to new channels, mainly SMS.
  • We currently get a 34x ROI from our Acoustic investment.

Alternatives Considered

Bluecore and Klaviyo

Other Software Used

Yotpo, HiConversion

IBM Watson Campaign Automation Review

Pros

  • A/B testing
  • Customer journey building
  • Performance insights and reporting

Cons

  • Product documentation
  • AI-powered Watson Assistant
  • Email personalization

Return on Investment

  • Lead Scoring and Grading
  • Segmentation
  • Budgeting

Alternatives Considered

HubSpot, Marketo, Pardot and ActiveCampaign

Other Software Used

Clearbit, DiscoverOrg, LinkedIn Marketing Solutions